Evaluation of the effects in the in vitro system of synthetic thymic hexapeptide on the expression levels of NF-κB, IFNα/βR and CD119 neutrophilic granulocytes in patients with chronic herpes viral co-infections

Full Text

Introduction

Diseases caused by viral agents are one of the most urgent and difficult to solve in the modern medicine. Large DNA-containing enveloped viruses that can interact with various cells of the human body in several ways. Those viruses are causing the development of both acute infections (lytic pathway) and the formation of chronic, often atypical, active forms of infection. Viral genome integrates in different human cells that lead to the persistence of viruses.

Among those viruses, the most interesting is the Herpesviridae family that includes 8 representatives. The Epstein–Barr virus (EBV) is one of the most striking. The viruses of this family are characterized by the formation of both mono- and mixed infections, often with the addition of bacterial, fungal or mixed nature co-infections. The viral interaction strategies with human cells are very complex and multifaceted. On the one hand, there are congenital defects of the antiviral mechanisms of immune defense, including the interferon system [8, 22, 26, 30]. Those innate mistakes of antiviral immune defense lead to the development of recurrent and persistent viral infections, such as repeated respiratory viral infections, chronic herpes viral infections, papillomavirus infections and so on.

On the other hand, many viruses themselves are capable to damage both the immune system and the interferon system. In both cases of innate or acquired defects of the interferon system, congenital or induced genes’ mutation of the molecules involved in signaling pathway is observed. Today well known those genes’ mutation: TLR3, interferon-regulating factors 3, 7, interferon receptors, interferon-stimulated genes, NF-kB, etc. The existing of innate or secondary genes’ mutations leads to a violation of the synthesis of IFN type I: IFNα and IFNβ. One of the strategies of viruses is to disrupt a number of cellular signaling pathways — transcription factors, especially NF-kB [2, 4, 11, 16, 25].

Transcription factors (TFs) are a large group of proteins that interact with DNA at specific regulatory regions (loci), which entails changing gene transcription (activation or inhibition) using domains transactivation or trans-repression [10, 40]. TFs are involved in the immunopathogenesis of a wide range of human diseases. The nuclear factor NF-kB is one of the most important in those protein groups. For the first time in 1986, Sen and Baltimore discovered transcription factors of the NF-kB family as specific for B cells [27]. Later it was shown, that the constitutive activation of NF-kB triggers the expression of a huge array of genes associated with the regulation of the immune response, inflammation, including apoptotic resistance, migration and angiogenesis. In this constitutive activation the NF-kB-sensitive genes TNF, IL-1, IL-6, IL-8 CXC-chemokine ligands are involved [24].

In addition, it is known that the activation of the nuclear factor NF-kB is the main mechanism that implements the antiviral activity of the innate immunity. This mechanism can be triggered by various signals induced by the microenvironment. They activate cellular receptors and induce intracellular signaling, by activating the genes of molecules involved in signaling.

However, it should be noted that some of these activated genes, in turn, can target NF-kB. In this case, there is another mechanism. For example, one of the main activated target genes of NF-kB is Isystem Bá, that blocks the activation of NF-kB [9, 35].

In works Zhang J and Kim JC it was shown experimentally that the HSV-1 UL2 protein and ICP27 can counteract the activation of NF-kB mediated by tumor necrosis factor á (TNFá) and IkappaBalpha [15, 20, 33, 39]. At the same time, the works of other authors have demonstrated that proteins that are part of the structure of the virion of herpes viruses negatively affect various parts of the NF-kB signaling cascade [1]. Those proteins can act through other mediators and signaling pathways leading to long-term, active expression of NF-kB. According to the data, it has been shown that the insertion of EBV into neutrophilic granulocytes (NG) can induce the transition of NG to apoptosis and multidirectionally activate the intracellular signaling pathways, in particular, the cascade of the nuclear factor NF-kB activation [3]. Currently, the antiviral activity of NG has been described. Upon that, the mechanisms of NG antiviral protection and, in particular, the features of NF-kB expression are not covered in the literature.

At the same time, there is practically no data in the modern scientific literature on the features of NF-kB expression in herpes virus co-infections, including atypical chronic active herpes viral co-infections (AChA-HVI). Taking into account the information given above, there is an urgent need for further studies of an expression features of the nuclear factor NF-kB NG in patients suffering from AChA-HVI co-infections

Purpose of the study: to study in the in vitro system the features of the expression of nuclear factor NF-kB and the expression of membrane receptors IFNα/βR and IFNγ (CD119) of neutrophilic granulocytes (NG) in patients suffering from ACHA-HVI, followed by an assessment of the effect of arginyl-alpha-aspartyl-lysyl-valyl-tyrosyl-arginine hexapeptide, a synthetic analogue of the active center of the hormone thymopoietin, on the expression of factor NF-kB and the expression of membrane receptors IFNα/βR and IFNγ (CD119) of NG.

Materials and methods

We observed 25 patients of both sexes aged 23 to 64 years suffering from atypical chronic active herpes virus infections (ACHA-HVI), manifested by chronic fatigue syndrome and various cognitive disorders (the main study group is MSG). This group of patients is characterized by a certain symptom complex. To assess the severity of clinical symptoms of CFS, we used a 5-point scale developed by us. The presence or absence of symptoms, depending on the severity of their manifestation, was evaluated in points from 0 to 5, where: 0 points — absence of symptoms; 1 point — minimal symptoms; 2 points — average severity of symptoms; 3 points — severe degree; 4 points — very severe degree; 5 points — critical severe degree. The control group (CG) consisted of 8 practically healthy individuals corresponding to gender and age.

Study design

Stage 1. In the complex of the study, in addition to traditional methods (collection of anamnesis, methods of physical examination, CBC, etc.), serodiagnostic methods were used to detect herpes virus infections (IgM VCA EBV, IgG VCA EBV, IgM CMV, IgG CMV IgM HSV1/2, IgG HSV1/2) using ELISA test systems RPA “Diagnostic Systems” (Russia). To detect the genome of viruses in biomaterials (blood, saliva, urine, scraping from the tonsils and the posterior pharyngeal wall), the PCR method of the “AmpliSens” test system (Russia) was used.

Stage 2. In the in vitro system, 32 blood samples from 8 apparently healthy adults and 375 blood samples from 25 patients with AChA-HVI were examined. The amount (%) of peripheral blood NG expressing the nuclear factor NF-kB, membrane receptors for IFNα/βR, IFNγ (CD119) and the intensity of their expression according to MFI were estimated by flow cytometry using an FC 500 flow cytometer (Beckman Coulter, USA) (value of fluorescence intensity) before and after incubation with hexapeptide (name of the substance according to the nomenclature of international non-proprietary names — INN, ATX code: L03AX).

The study was approved by the Ethics Commission, and informed consent was obtained from all patients to participate in the study and to process personal data in accordance with the World Medical Association’s Declaration of Helsinki (WMA Declaration of Helsinki — Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects, 2013).

For statistical processing of the data obtained, Microsoft Excel computer programs were used. The results were presented as the median (upper and lower quartile) Me [Q₁; Q₃], Mann–Whitney and Wilcoxon tests. The significance of the difference was determined at p < 0.05.

Results

When analyzing the clinical material, it was found that all patients of the main study group suffered from mixed AChA-HVI in 100% of cases. The dominant combinations were: EBV + CMV + HHV6 — 52%, EBV + HSV1 — 36%; EBV + CMV — 12% of cases. It is important to note that EBV was the predominant virus found in all patient’s groups. A number of clinical features of mixed AChA-HVI has been identified: a prolonged feeling of severe weakness, chronic fatigue, in addition, patients worried about sweating, intermittent pain in the throat, muscles and joints (fibromyalgia and arthralgia), headaches, low-grade fever, lymphadenopathy, sleep disturbance, decreased memory, attention, intelligence, less often — psychogenic depression. Often patients suffered from virus-associated recurrent ARVI, chronic repeated herpes-viral infections (HSV1, HSV2), chronic CMV and HHV6 infections, chronic bacterial and fungal infections. Diseases associated with AChA-HVI were characterized by a recurrent course.

All these symptoms were assessed according to our 5-point scale (Table 1). The severity of symptoms on this scale was Me [Q₁; Q₃] — 44.5 [37.5; 51.5].

 

Table 1. Assessment scale of clinical symptom severity for post-viral chronic fatigue syndrome

Symptoms	Score Me [Q1; Q3]
Long term low grade fever	4,0 [3, 5; 4, 5]
Throat pain and discomfort	4,0 [3, 5; 4, 5]
Increased sweatiness, sensitivity to cold	3,5 [2, 5; 4, 5]
Headache, migraine	4,0 [3, 5; 4, 5]
Regional lymphadenopathy	4,5 [4, 0; 5, 0]
Increased fatigue, a significant decrease in efficiency	5,0 [5, 0; 5, 0]
Neurological disorders (paraesthesia, synaesthesia, sensitivity disorders, low muscle tone, etc.)	4,5 [4, 0; 5, 0]
Decrease in memory processes, difficulty concentrating	3,0 [1, 5; 4, 5]
Headaches, joint pain, myalgia	3,5 [2, 5; 4, 5]
Sleep disorders (insomnia or increased drowsiness)	4,0 [3, 5; 4, 5]
Panic attacks, mood disorders, emotional lability, psychogenic depression etc.	4,5 [4, 0; 5, 0]
Total Score	44,5 [37, 5; 51, 5]

 

The diagnosis of AChA-HVI was confirmed by serodiagnostic methods, molecular genetic methods (PCR); in addition, violations of the induced IFNα production in 100,0% and a deficiency of the induced IFNγ production in 76,0% of cases were found. The patients of the main study group had a pronounced decrease in the induced production of IFNα to 85 [50; 120] ME/ml and IFNγ to 16 [4; 28] ME/ml.

Analysis of the data obtained showed that in conditionally healthy individuals (control group), the number of NGs expressing nuclear factor NF-kB was 100%, while MFI, assessing the level of expression of nuclear factor NF-kB, was 8.9 [8,7; 10.1]. In addition, it was shown that in the main study group (MG), as in the control group, 100% of NG expressed the nuclear factor NF-kB. However, in comparison with CG, a significant decrease in the level of expression of NF-kB according to MFI was revealed to 5.1 [4.5; 6.5] (p < 0.05) (Fig. 1).

 

Figure 1. Expression levels of nuclear factor NF-κB in neutrophilic granulocytes of patients suffering from AChA-HVI and in control group (conditionally healthy individuals) according to MFI distribution

Note. *Differences from control group.

 

In addition, it was found that in patients of the control group, the number of NGs expressing membrane IFNα/βR was 4.55 [2.3; 7.2]% with MFI 1.19 [1.15; 1.22], and membrane CD119 (IFNγR) — 19.9 [14.3; 27.6]% with MFI 1.48 [1.1; 2.2]. In the main study group (MSG), the number of NGs expressing IFNα/βR was significantly reduced to 1.0 [0.6; 1.9]% (p < 0.05) with MFI 1.71 [1.61; 1.91], and the number of NG expressing CD119 (IFNγR) had an insignificant upward trend and amounted to 39.5 [28.7; 48.6]% with MFI 1.48 [1.35; 1.75] (Table 2).

 

Table 2. Comparative characteristics of the expressed nuclear factor NF-kB, membrane IFNá/âR and CD119 (IFNãR) neutrophilic granulocytes in apparently healthy individuals and patients with AChA-HVI

Before the in vitro influence of a hexapeptide
	CD119 Me [Q1; Q2]		IFNα/βR Me [Q1; Q2]		NF-kB Me [Q1; Q2]
	%NG	MFI	%NG	MFI	%NG	MFI
Control group n = 6	19,9 [14, 3; 27, 6]	1,48 [1, 1; 2, 2]	4,55 [2, 3; 7, 2]	1,19 [1, 15; 1, 22]	100	8,9 [8, 7; 10, 1]
Main study group n = 25	39,5* [28, 7; 48, 6]	1,48 [1, 35; 1, 75]	1* [0, 6; 1, 9]	1,71* [1, 61; 1, 91]	100	5,1* [4, 5; 6, 5]
Under the in vitro influence of a hexapeptide
	CD119		IFNα/βR		NF-kB
Study group 1 n = 13	56,0*♦ [49, 6; 58, 2]	1,68 [1, 5; 1, 9]	1,65* [1, 5; 1, 8]	1,7 [1, 6; 2, 0]	100	5,5* [5, 4; 5, 6]
Study group 2 n = 12	32,3*# [30, 2; 48, 1]	1,5 [1, 3; 1, 6]	3,81♦# [3, 8; 4, 2]	1,7 [1, 6; 2, 0]	100	7,5*♦# [6, 9; 8, 0]

Note. *Differences from control group; ^♦differences from MSG (main study group); ^#differences SG 1 and SG 2 (study group 1 and study group 2).

 

An in vitro experiment was carried out in which the effect of HP on the expression of the nuclear factor NF-kB and the number of NGs expressing IFNα/βR and IFNγ was assessed in apparently healthy individuals and patients suffering from AChA-HVI.

It was found that under the influence of a hexapeptide (HP) in the MSG, the population of NG expressing the nuclear factor NF-kB is divided into two subgroups: Study Group 1 (SG 1) and Study Group 2 (SG 2). The levels of NF-kB expression were significantly differ in SG 1 and SG 2. In SG 2 a more high level of MFI NF-kB — 7.5 [6.9; 8.0] was detected than in SG 1, in which the level of MFI NF-kB was only 5.5 [5.4; 5.6] (p < 0.01). After HP influence the level of NF-kB NG expression according to MFI was 5.5 [5.4; 7.5] in the SG 1 and did not significantly differ from the decreased level of MFI NF-kB in the MG before HP exposure — MFI 5.1 [4.5; 6.5] (p ≥ 0.01). Moreover, the level of MFI NF-kB NG expression in SG 2 increased after HP influence from 5.1 [4.5; 6.5] to 7.5 [6.9; 8.0] (p < 0.01). At the same time, it was significantly higher than it was been in SG 1 — 5.5 [5.4; 5.6] (p < 0.05) and didn’t significantly change from the level of MFI NF-kB in the CG — 8.9 [8.7; 10.1] (p < 0.05) (Fig. 2).

 

Figure 2 Comparison of the expression levels (MFI) for NF-kB in neutrophilic granulocytes from patients with AChA-HVI before and after exposure to HP in in vitro experimental system

Note. *Differences from control group; ^♦differences from MSG (main study group); ^#differences SG1 and SG2 (study group 1 and study group 2).

 

Under the influence of hexapeptide (HP), the NG population in the MSG was divided into two groups (SG 1 and SG 2) according to the number of NGs expressing membrane IFNα/βR and IFNγ (CD119) (Fig. 3).

 

Figure 3. Count of NG expressing membrane receptors IFNα/βR and IFNγ (CD119) before and after HP exposure in patients suffering from AChA-HVI

Note. *Differences from control group; ^♦differences from MSG (main study group); ^#differences SG1 and SG2 (study group 1 and study group 2).

 

After influence of HP in SG 1 (52% of cases) an insignificant increasing of NG number (%) expressing membrane IFNα/βR from 1.0 [0.6; 1.9] to 1.65 [1.5; 1.8]% was revealed in comparison with the MG (p > 0.05). The expression level of surface membrane IFNα/βR NG according MFI did not change in comparison with the MG too (p > 0.05). Meanwhile there was a significant increasing in the number of level NG, expressing membrane CD119 (IFNγR) from 39.5 [28.7; 48.6]% to 56.0 [49.6; 58.2]% (p < 0.05) after exposure of HP. This fact indicates that the number NG, expressing membrane CD119 (IFNγR) was increased by 1.42 times or by 41.7%. The expression level of surface membrane CD119 (IFNγR) NG according MFI data did not change (p > 0.05).

At the same time after exposure of HP an ambiguous effect of HP on the levels of NG expressing membrane IFNα/βR and CD119 (IFNγR) was revealed in the SG 2 (48% of cases). HP has influenced on the level of NG, expressing membrane IFNα/βR in SG 2, significantly increasing its number from 1.00 [0.6; 1.9]% in MG to 3.81 [3.8; 4.2]% in SG 2 (p < 0.05) and reached the NG level of CG (p > 0.05). At the same time after influence of HP the expression level according to MFI data of membrane IFNα/βR NG in SG 2 did not change in comparison with group CG and MG (p_1,2 > 0.05).

There was an insignificant decreasing in comparison with MSG in the number of the NG (%), expressing membrane CD119 (IFNγR) from 39.5 [28.7; 48.6]% to 32.3 [30.2; 48.1]% (p > 0.05). Meanwhile there was a significant increasing in the level of NG, expressing membrane CD119 (IFNγR), from 19.9 [14.3; 27.6]% to 32.3 [30.2; 48.1]%, in comparison with CG (p > 0.05). After influence of HP the expression level according to MFI data of membrane CD119 (IFNγR) NG in SG 2 did not change in comparison with group CG and MSG (p_1,2 > 0.05).

Discussion

The problem of treating patients with chronic active herpes virus infections is still very far from being solved. Taking into account that EBV is present in all identified combinations of herpes-viral co-infections and is the dominant infection in the patients included in this study (AHI). Also it’s important to consider its negative effect on the nuclear factor NF-kB and membrane receptors IFNá/âR NG, CD119 (IFNγR) expressing by NG.

According to the literature, EBV BGLF2 protein inhibits two key proteins STAT1 and STAT2, which are involved in the stage 2 signaling of type I IFN synthesis. In addition, BGLF2 recruits host cell enzymes to remove the phosphate group from STAT1, thereby inactivating its activity and redirecting STAT2 to degradation. It leads to defective ISG expression and disruption of type I IFN synthesis, and, consequently, to a decrease in IFN type I antiviral and immunomodulatory activity [6, 7, 13, 14, 18, 19, 28, 29, 32, 33, 34, 37]. These data confirm the damaging effect of EBV, that causes the occurrence of secondary defects in the expression of not only NF-kB, but also membrane receptors IFNα/βR NG, and do not contradict the results obtained by us during the present study.

It should be noted that earlier in the works of foreign authors the presence of congenital errors of immunity such as primary immunodeficiencies caused by mutations in the genes STAT1/STAT2, TLR3, UNC93B1, TICAM1, TBK1, IRF3, IRF7, IFNAR1, IFNAR2, which explains the deficiency of spontaneous and induced production of IFN I type was shown [17, 21, 23, 31, 36, 38]. In this regard, the likelihood of congenital disorders of the interferon system in patients with AChA-HVI (SG 1) is not excluded. It is confirmed by the lack of an adequate NF-kB response to the effect of HP in the in vitro system and explains the occurrence of atypical herpes-viral co-infections.

On the other hand, according to our data and according to the literature, autoimmune diseases in parallel with atypical chronic active EBV infection can manifest in patients with a genetic predisposition. There is also evidence that chronic EBV infection can lead to an increase in the expression of the nuclear factor NF-kB, which, in turn, can provoke the development of autoimmune diseases and tumor processes [5, 12]. It should be emphasized that we did not observe autoimmune disorders and tumor processes in patients of MG. At the same time we noted the leading syndrome of chronic fatigue, myalgia, arthralgia and the syndrome of minor cognitive disorders that did not exclude the presence of neuroinflammatory changes.

In conclusion, we would like to note that the results obtained in this study allow us to clarify the immunopathogenesis of atypical chronic active herpes virus co-infections associated with the prevalence of EBV infection. The data obtained on the positive effect of in vitro HP on the restoration of the nuclear factor NF-kB expression level, as well as the expression of membrane receptors IFNα/βR NG in, presumably, secondary defects of the interferon system, accompanied by deficiency of type I and II IFNs. These results can serve as a basis for further development of the strategy and tactics of immunotherapy with using active substance HP (“Imunofan”, Russia) for restoration of the level of expression of NF-kB NG with further reconstruction of secondary defects of interferon system. This immunomodulatory drug based on the active substance HP may be used in future in clinical practice.

Conclusion

The data obtained made it possible to come to the main conclusions:

1. There is a violation of the nuclear factor NF-kB expression associated with a decrease in the level of number NG expressing membrane receptors IFNα/βR and CD119 (IFNγR) in all patients suffering from AChA-HVI with the deficiencies of a serum IFNα and IFNγ.
2. In the in vitro experiment, HP exhibited different effects of influences on the levels of nuclear factor NF-kB expression (MFI) and the level of number NG expressing membrane IFNα/βR NG and membrane IFNγR in patients with AChA-HVI:
   
   • there were a significant restoration of the nuclear factor NF-kB NG expression to the level of healthy individuals in NG of 48% patients with AChA-HVI (SG 2) and a significant increasing in the level of number NG expressing membrane IFNα/βR, while the level of number NG expressing IFNγR has not changed;
   • in 52% of AChA-HVI (SG 1) patients the level of NF-kB NG expression and the level of number NG expressing IFNα/βR NG has not significantly changed, while there was a significant increasing in the level of number NG expressing of membrane IFNγR
3. Restoration of the expression of NF-kB NG in 48% patients suffering from AChA-HVI under the influence of HP in the experiment may indicate secondary damage to the expression of NF-kB that occurred under the damaging influences of herpes viral co-infections. The absence of an effect of HP on the level of expression NF-kB in 52% patients with AChA-HVI evidences about deeper damages of NF-kB expression, possibly due to congenital disorders expression of NF-kB. However these assumptions require carrying out of further research.
4. These results may serve as a basis for further development of the strategy and tactics of immunomodulate therapy with using active substance HP of drug “Imunofan” (Russia) for restoration of secondary defects of expression of NF-kB, the level of number NG, expressing membrane IFNα/βR, IFNγR and for the reconstruction of normal functioning of the interferon system in patients with AChA-HVI.

About the authors

I. V. Nesterova

The Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia; Kuban State Medical University

Email: inesterova1@yandex.ru

PhD, MD (Medicine), Professor, Department of Allergology and Immunology

Russian Federation, Moscow; Krasnodar

E. O. Khalturina

I.M. Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University (Sechenov University)

Author for correspondence.
Email: jane_k@inbox.ru

PhD (Medicine), Associate Professor, Department of Microbiology, Virology and Immunology

Russian Federation, Moscow

V. N. Nelubin

Moscow State University of Medicine and Dentistry

Email: vlnelyubin@mail.ru

PhD, MD (Medicine), Professor

Russian Federation, Moscow

S. V. Khaidukov

Shemyakin-Ovchinnikov Institute of Bioorganic Chemistry

Email: hsv@mail.ibch.ru

PhD, MD (Biology), Senior Researcher, Carbohydrate Laboratory

Russian Federation, Moscow

G. A. Chudilova

Kuban State Medical University

Email: chudilova2015@yandex.ru

PhD, MD (Biology), Associate Professor, Department of Clinical Immunology, Allergology and Laboratory Diagnostics

Russian Federation, Krasnodar

References

Supplementary files